• LAT Home
  • |
  • My LATimes
  • |
  • Print Edition
  • |
  • All Sections
  • More Classifieds
  • |
  • Foreclosure Sale
  • |
  • Real Estate
  • |
  • Cars.com
  • |
  • Jobs
Los Angeles Times The Guide

Search LATimes

  • Restaurants
  • Bars & Clubs
  • Events
  • Music
  • Art & Museums
  • Theater & Stage
  • Outdoors
  • Movies
  • TV
  • Neighborhoods
 
calendarlive

Movies

In Movies

  • Movie Reviews
  • Movie News

Partners

Classifieds

  • Careers
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Rentals
  • Times Guides
  • Newspaper Ads
  • Grocery Coupons
  • Personals

March 17, 2006 E-mail story   Print  

MOVIE REVIEW

'Don't Come Knocking'

'Knocking' reunites actor-writer Sam Shepard and director Wim Wenders, but the Montana location steals the show.
 
Old flames
Old flames
(Donata Wenders / Sony Pictures Classics)

Find Movie Showtimes & Tickets
Search by Title:
OR
By Zip Code:

Reader Reviews
-The New Twenty
-Boogie Man: The Lee Atwater Story
-Shoot on Sight
-Forever Strong
-Hounddog
-Garden Party

Times Reviews
-'Turning Green'
-'Died Young, Stayed Pretty,' about rock poster artists, loses focus
-'Precious' cuts deep
-Robert Zemeckis' 'Christmas Carol': Bah humbug. Too many special effects
-'The Box'
-'The Men Who Stare at Goats'
-'Araya'
-'The Fourth Kind'
-'Precious' info
-'The Box' info
-'A Christmas Carol'
-'1939 Redux': Series digs beyond the classics of 'Hollywood's Greatest Year'


 Movie Reviews
'Turning Green'
'Died Young, Stayed Pretty,' about rock poster artists, loses focus
'Precious' cuts deep
Robert Zemeckis' 'Christmas Carol': Bah humbug. Too many special effects
'The Box'
Movie Reviews section >

 Most E-mailed
Adam Lambert: Cool, calm and eclectic
'Precious' cuts deep
'The Proposal'
> more e-mailed stories

By Kevin Crust, Times Staff Writer

"Don't Come Knocking" opens with a bandit mask view of blue sky and fluffy white clouds where the eyes should be. A reverse shot reveals it to be a panoramic vista of rocks near Moab, Utah, with Sam Shepard on horseback high-tailing it from somewhere or another.

We quickly learn he's a washed-up movie star named Howard Spence who has gone AWOL from the set of a western in which he is starring. A 60-year-old drug- and alcohol-abusing playboy, Howard heads for home in Elko, Nev., a place he hasn't been in 30 years.

ADVERTISEMENT
The film marks the reunion of screenwriter Shepard and director Wim Wenders, whose earlier collaboration, "Paris, Texas," won the Palme d'Or at Cannes in 1984. Though "Don't Come Knocking" revels in themes both men have had success with, its narrative kinks and improbabilities reduce it to an unsatisfying allegory. Despite a fine cast, the film feels as lost as Howard, unsure of its direction or tone.

Howard's departure leaves the film set in turmoil, its director (George Kennedy) frustrated and its female lead (Marley Shelton) unable to perform with a stand-in. A no-nonsense representative of the bond company, Sutter (Tim Roth), swoops in by helicopter and begins tracking the wayward cowboy.

In Elko, Howard's reunion with his elderly mother (Eva Marie Saint) is cut short by the revelation that he has a twentysomething son from a long-ago encounter on a film shoot in Butte, Mont. He heads off in his late father's Packard, unsure of what's ahead.

Meanwhile, a young woman named Sky (Sarah Polley) arrives in Butte carrying an urn with her recently deceased mother's ashes. Howard and Sky intersect at the restaurant run by Howard's old flame, Doreen (Jessica Lange), who seems more bemused than anything to see her long-gone lover. Earl (Gabriel Mann), Howard and Doreen's moody musician son, is not eager to embrace his father, and the film becomes a roundelay of awkward offers and refusals of rapprochement.

Butte may well give the performance of the movie, upstaging the more cinematically familiar Utah desert. The town's deserted streets look both beautiful and haunted — nicely rendered by cinematographer Franz Lustig — and feed Wenders' fondness for an American West etched with loneliness.

The angelic Polley moves through the film with beatific grace, gently guiding the other characters toward a conclusion. As frustrating and elliptical as the film's first half is, there an abstract peace that settles in by its end. Unfortunately, the mystery that engulfs Shepard's best plays, imbuing his dysfunctional families with a sense of drama and tragedy, is missing here.

'Don't Come Knocking'

MPAA rating: R for language and brief nudity





To order a reprint of this article, please click here.

 
 
 

More in The Guide

Restaurants | Bars & Clubs | Events | Music | Art | Performing Arts | Movies | TV |

More on LATimes.com

California/Local | National | World | Sports | Business | Entertainment | Travel | Health | Autos | Real Estate

Classifieds

CareerBuilder.com | Cars.com | Apartments.com | OpenHouses.com | FSBO (For Sale by Owner)

Partners

ViveloHoy | KTLA | Metromix | Zap2it
Los Angeles Times
202 West 1st Street, Los Angeles, California, 90012
Copyright 2008 Los Angeles Times
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Home Delivery | Permissions | Help & Services | Contact | Site Map